The Gay Man Iceland Wants to Silence: Inside a "Gender Gilead" - Eldur Smári Kristinsson (#24)
Stella O'Malley speaks with Eldur Smári Kristinsson, chairman of Iceland's Lesbian and Gay Alliance, a gay activist now facing his third criminal investigation for criticising gender-identity ideology. In one of the most striking conversations in this series, Kristinsson describes how a nation of 400,000 became what he calls a dystopian gender Gilead—and what it costs, in concrete legal and personal terms, to be the person saying so out loud.
Eldur Smári Kristinsson did not set out to become a dissident. As chairman of Samtökin 22, Iceland's Lesbian and Gay Alliance, he built his activism around gay rights in a country that considered itself a model of progressive values. The turning point, he tells Stella O'Malley, came when he began questioning the expectation that gay men must accept what he calls "girl dick"—the idea that same-sex attraction is exclusionary unless it extends to transgender-identifying people. That single pressure point led him somewhere he could not have anticipated: facing the Icelandic state in court, repeatedly. Iceland has a population of around 400,000, and Kristinsson argues this is precisely what made it so susceptible to near-total institutional capture. When the same small circle of politicians, journalists, and activists share the same assumptions, dissent becomes not just difficult but legally dangerous. He describes kindergarteners returning home and asking their parents whether they can change sex, and sex education that frames BDSM as a sexual orientation. What strikes him most is not the ideology itself but the silence—the near-total absence of any public figure willing to say, openly, that something has gone wrong. The personal cost of being the exception has been significant. Kristinsson is now facing his third criminal investigation, each stemming from social media posts that comment critically on gender-identity claims. One case concerns a post about male breastfeeding. Under Iceland's hate speech framework, these are not minor civil matters but police investigations. He now carries hidden recording equipment when he appears in public—a detail that speaks, without any editorialising, to how drastically his sense of personal safety has shifted. Stella brings her characteristic care to the conversation, pressing on the paradox that runs through Kristinsson's story: a gay rights activist who finds the institutions built to defend people like him have become the instruments of his prosecution. The episode works through how this transformation happened—not through dramatic confrontation but through the quiet, rapid alignment of progressive parties, media, and civil society around an ideology that foreclosed internal criticism before most people noticed what was being foreclosed. Kristinsson's closing message is simple and direct: he needs the world to see what is happening in Iceland. By the end of this conversation, the listener understands why. Iceland is not an isolated anomaly—it is a small country where social conformism, progressive credentialism, and powerful hate speech laws combined earlier and more completely than elsewhere. What Kristinsson is living through may be less a warning about Iceland than a preview of what happens when these forces are given enough room.
Watch and subscribe on YouTube
Open this episode on the Beyond Gender channel
