Scott Wiener has passed abhorrent bills related to sex and gender.

9 November 2026

Stella O'Malley, Mia Hughes and Dr Bret Alderman turn their attention to California, where state senator Scott Wiener has built a legislative record on sex and gender that the hosts describe bluntly as abhorrent. From a gender-critical vantage point, the episode asks what happens when lawmakers, rather than clinicians, parents or evidence, become the driving force behind policy on children's bodies and identities. Expect a frank discussion of political power, accountability and the gap between activist-driven lawmaking and the therapeutic caution the hosts have spent years advocating for.

This episode of Beyond Gender takes aim at the legislative record of Scott Wiener, the California state senator whose bills on sex and gender have repeatedly drawn national attention. Stella O'Malley, Mia Hughes and Dr Bret Alderman use his record as a case study in how far gender-identity politics has travelled from the therapy room into statehouses, and what gets lost along the way when legislators move faster than the evidence. Wiener has long been one of the most visible champions of gender-identity legislation in American state politics, pushing bills that touch on parental rights, access to medical interventions, and the broader legal architecture around how sex and gender are treated in law. The hosts do not approach this as a neutral policy briefing. They are explicit that they regard these bills as harmful, and the episode works through why, tracing the consequences for children, families and clinicians caught in the middle of rules written by politicians rather than by those doing the clinical work. For a podcast built around the perspectives of a psychotherapist, a researcher and a psychologist, legislation is never just an abstract policy question. Stella O'Malley's clinical experience, Mia Hughes's research into gender medicine and advocacy networks, and Bret Alderman's psychological lens all bring a different kind of scrutiny to a lawmaker's record than a typical political analysis would. They are interested in what happens on the ground: to the teenager whose access to therapy or information is shaped by statute, to the parent whose rights are redefined by a bill passed in Sacramento, to the clinician whose caution is overridden by legal mandate. This matters a great deal from where this podcast sits. Beyond Gender has consistently argued that decisions about children's gender distress should be grounded in evidence, careful psychotherapy and open debate, not foreclosed by ideology or fast-tracked through legislatures. A single senator amassing a long list of bills on sex and gender is, for these hosts, a symptom of exactly the dynamic they warn about: policy outpacing evidence, and dissenting clinical voices getting squeezed out of the conversation entirely. Listeners can expect the hosts to unpack specific aspects of Wiener's legislative approach, question the assumptions behind it, and situate it within the wider pattern of gender-identity ideology embedding itself in law across the United States. It is likely to resonate with listeners already following the California political landscape, as well as anyone trying to understand how a single legislator can reshape medical and parental norms through the ordinary machinery of a state senate. As ever, the episode positions itself as a corrective to a narrower public conversation, bringing therapeutic and research expertise to a story usually told in purely political terms. For an audience that values scepticism toward unchecked institutional and political momentum on these issues, this is a pointed, opinionated entry in the back catalogue, one that treats a politician's bill record as fair game for the same evidence-based scrutiny the hosts apply to clinics, schools and professional bodies elsewhere.

More recent episodes