The Pathologisation of Parenting | Ellie Lee
Professor Ellie Lee has spent decades researching how parenthood became a therapeutic enterprise — and what that shift means for children. In this conversation with Stella O'Malley, Mia Hughes and Dr Bret Alderman, she traces the rise of therapy culture from its roots in reproductive politics through to diagnosis culture in schools, the erosion of adult authority and, ultimately, the medical treatment of gender-distressed young people. Scholarly in its depth but accessible in its range, it is one of the most contextually rich episodes the podcast has produced.
Ellie Lee holds a chair in Family and Parenting Research at the University of Kent and directs its Centre for Parenting Culture Studies. She has spent years tracing how parenthood — once understood as an ordinary, if demanding, adult role — has been progressively recast as a high-stakes therapeutic project. That body of work takes on new urgency when placed alongside the current debate about gender-distressed children and the clinical pathways they are being led along. The conversation opens with a thread Lee has followed since her early research on abortion and reproductive politics: the way major life experiences get drawn into a medical and therapeutic frame. She calls it therapy culture — a set of assumptions that translate normal difficulty into disorder, position adults as emotionally fragile and treat professional intervention as the appropriate response to almost any problem. Her argument is not that therapy is worthless; it is that its idioms have spread far beyond the consulting room and reshaped how institutions, schools and families think about themselves. One of the most striking ideas in the episode is what Lee describes as a reversal of authority. Across a long historical arc, she traces a shift from models of parenting grounded in adult guidance toward child-led approaches in which parental instinct is treated as potentially harmful and expert opinion as the necessary corrective. The hosts press her on where that shift began — a discussion that touches on the expansion of child psychology, the professionalisation of parenting advice and the gradual erosion of confidence in ordinary adult judgment. The episode also examines diagnosis culture in children: the rising prevalence of labels, the mainstreaming of conditions such as PDA (Pathological Demand Avoidance), and the consequences of framing children's behaviour primarily through a clinical lens. Stella O'Malley, drawing on her own practice as a psychotherapist, brings a texture to the exchange that keeps it grounded — she knows the research literature, but she also knows real families navigating these pressures in real time. The connection to gender-distressed children arrives naturally rather than as a detour. If parents have already been taught to distrust their own judgment, to defer to professionals and to read their child's distress as a medical signal requiring specialist intervention, then the pathway to affirmative care becomes easier to understand — not as a conspiracy but as the logical endpoint of a cultural transformation decades in the making. Lee's research provides a framework for seeing how good intentions and therapeutic ideology can converge in ways that harm the very children they claim to help. The episode closes with a search for grounds for optimism, and Lee — a careful, empirically minded sociologist — is measured but not despairing. It is one of the more intellectually substantial conversations Beyond Gender has produced.
Watch and subscribe on YouTube
Open this episode on the Beyond Gender channel
